Search the Web 

 

 

 

 

Cow-Agriculture


STUDY OF COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF ORGANIC MANURE AND CHEMICAL FERTILIZERS

ORGANIC MANURE CHEMICAL FERTILIZERS
1. It is natural food and nutrient for soil and crop. 1. This is synthetic and unnatural food.
2. Besides nitrogen and potassium substances it contains 16 other necessary nutrients. 2. Such nutritious elements are totally absent.
3. Improves texture of the soil and its fertility.  3. Damages the texture of the Gradual increasing use makes soil weaker and weaker day by day and it becomes ultimately barren. Increase in use raises the cost of production also.
4. Promotes growth of earth worm and such other creatures which increase the fertility of the soil and make it powdery. When the soil becomes powdery; air, water and light flow freely into the soil which maintain humidity and temperature of the soil and this controls pests. 4. Earth worms and other creatures which help increase of fertility of the soil get destroyed by use of chemical fertiliser. The soil becomes hard. The ploughing expenses increase and instead of bullocks the farmer has to resort to tractor and later on tractor with more power.
5. At the time of scanty rains the soil holds water if farmyard manure is used. In case of excessive rain, water is drained out. During extreme cold the soil remains warm. 5. Due to weak holding capacity for water and humidity, soil needs repeated irrigation. There is scarcity of irrigation water in most of the Indian villages. Further the soil is unable to protect itself against extreme hot or extreme cold conditions.
6. The nourishment is provided slowly to the plants so that through out the life of the plant nourishment is available and hence the amount spent on organic manure gets maximum return. Its effect remains for 1 to 2 years. 6. Chemical fertiliser gets dissolved immediately on application and hence in case of excessive rain, either it seeps into the soil or flows away with water. In conditions of scanty rain it dries up the crop as it gets exhausted in short time. The full use of expenses incurred are not available. Its application is sufficient for one crop.
7. The crop grown with the help of farmyard manure can be preserved with the help of traditional substance, urine of cow, dung ash, dry leaves of neem tree or tobacco leaves. 7. Due to unnatural fast rate of growth the crop of food grains remain weak and becomes susceptible to the attack by pests. To save the crop from pests the twin brother of fertiliser i.e. pesticides are needed in large quantity.
8. In countries like America and Australia there is growing market for food grains and vegetables which are free from use of chemical fertilisers and pesticides. The crop grown without the use of chemical fertilisers, pesticides, fetch more than 1 to 2 times the usual prices. 8. Due to assimilation of poisonous substances in the soil as well as in crop, level of poisonous substances in then food of animals and human beings are increasing.
9. Manufacturing of compost manure takes care of disposal of dung, urine, household waste and other solid wastes. This helps in making the environment healthy and beautiful. 9. Use of chemical fertilisers creates pollution of the air, water, soil and vegetation.
10. The food grains, vegetables and fruits grown with the help of farmyard manure are pure, healthy, tasty and have longer shelf life. 10. The farm products rown with the help of chemical fertilisers are tasteless, harmful and perishable much faster.
11. The organic manure can be manufacture in one's own farm with the help of one's own family members and cattle. 11. Chemical fertilisers have to be either imported or manufactured in large plants. This drains away our wealth from our family, our village and our country.
12. Cattle dung. soil household  wastes, human and water which are the inputs for farmyard manures are easily available and are renewable sources of raw material 12. The raw-material or inputs for manufacture of chemical fertilisers are mineral and petroleum based which are not renewable sources. When these will exhaust in a few years there will be shortage of chemical fertilisers and because farming will be by then totally dependent on chemical fertilisers, no crop would be grown in the absence of chemical fertiliser.
13. The farmyard manure or organic manure can be manufactured by any person irrespective of his age, gender or level of literacy. The capital needed is also negligible. 13. The manufacturing process of chemical fertiliser is highly technical and beyond the comprehension of common man. It also require colossal capital and Thousands of technocrats.
14. As the farmyard manure is manufactured in the village and in the farm itself it can be easily transported with the help of human and cattle labors. This helps in preservation and development of our cattle wealth 14. The transportation of chemical fertiliser imposes a very heavy and yet unnecessary burden on all our means of transport such as rail, road and wearer transport. The energy required for this transportation is very costly, very limited and has to be imported. To purchase petrol and diesel from the Arab nations we have to export meat in return. This compels us to slaughter our precious cattle and even young claves. During 1972 our meat export was 2000 tons in a year. This has now increased to more than 1 lakh ton.
15. A farmyard manure is manufactured in the open atmosphere of the village, the relation between nature, human and cattle is mentioned due to their close co-operation. 15. The chemical fertilizers are processes in suffocating conditions in giant plants which affect the health of workers in these plants. The process also increase pollution.
16. Farmyard manure makes us self-reliant. 16. The farmer has become dependent on the industrialists, traders and foreign countries which control production of chemical fertilizer and the farmer is subjected to exploitation by all of them.
17. Farmyard manure and the agricultural activity dependent on farmyard manure opens up individual self-employment to crores of people in villages. This prevents their migration to cities and thus keep the family life intact. It helps in solving the problem of unemployment and disguised employment in rural areas. 17. Manufacturing of chemical fertilizers and allied activities can provide employment any to a few lakh of persons.



18. A total reliance on organic and farmyard manure will generate production of manure worth Rs.45,000 crores in villages. the production of farmyard manure in cities will be free from clutches of poverty, hunger and unemployment. The all additional production will be worth Rs.1 lakh crores. 18. Use of chemical fertilizer will drawn the nation in ocean of external debt and in times to come the manufacturing activity will come to a halt.

 

19.As farmyard manure is manufactured from cattle dung, the old and aged cattle will also become useful due to their dung yielding capacity. This will stall the slaughter of cow and its progenies and thus help in protection of our ancient Indian culture.

 

19. The system associated with use of chemical fertilizer is based on giant machinery and thus ultimately it will result in destruction of our cattle particularly the bullocks. Even today our country faces shortage of bullocks and we do not have sufficient number of tractors. We can never have sufficient number of tractors and even if we have, the diesel required to operate these tractor will not be available. The tractor will not survive on grass of fodder, it will not yield milk nor bullocks or fertilizer On the contrary it will only add to pollution.
20. The energy use in manufacturing of organic or farmyard manure is returned in the form of food grain. 20. The energy use in the manufacture of chemical fertilizer is not returned in the form of food rain production, and hence it proves a loosing proposition.
21. The seeds of crops grown with the help of farmyard manure have greater production capacity for future crops. 21. The seeds of crop grown with the help of chemical fertilizer do ot have this capacity.
22. Farmyard manure is a blessing for the human race. 22. Chemical fertilizer is a curse for the human race.

Back To Main

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 
  

Guest Register
. Online Membership . Members Login . Discussion Forum . Chat Room . Opinion Poll . Search .  About Us . Contact Us . Site Map . Cow- Agriculture .  Cow-Satyagraha . Cow-NGOs . Cow-Legislation . Cow-Gaushalas . Cow-Economy . Cow-Medicine . Cow-Eco System Bibliography . Goyigyan Bharati . Home

Powered by ScanTrax